THE SUPREME COURT OF SWAZILAND
NOVEMBER 2013 SESSION COURT ROLL
(CORRECTED VERSION)
JUDGES OF THE SUPREME COURT FOR THE SESSION:
M.M. RAMODIBEDI CJ; A.M. EBRAHIM JA;
S.A.MOORE JA;
DR. S. TWUM JA;
M.C.B. MAPHALALA JA;
E.A.OTA JA;
P. LEVINSOHN JA;
TO: Honourable Justices of Appeal
Honourable Justices of the High Court
Honourable Attorney General
The Director of Public Prosecutions
The Registrar of the High Court
The Commissioner of Police
The Commissioner of the Correctional Services
Their Worships the Magistrates
The Law Society of Swaziland
Legal Practitioners
Litigants in Person.
NB: There will be a roll call on Friday 1 November 2013 at 9.00 a.m. All Legal Practitioners or their representatives as well as litigants appearing in person are requested to attend the roll call. Take further notice that no postponements will be entertained except for good cause shown on written application and properly motivated in open court.
CRIMINAL AND CIVIL CASES
FRIDAY 1 NOVEMBER 2013
COURT A
1. C OF A (CRI) 17/2012
SANDILE MACHAWE MTSETFWA
V
REX
(In Person) (The DPP’s Office)
2. C OF A (CIVIL) 30/2012 (35/2013) THE PRIME MINISTER OF SWAZILAND AND OTHERS
V
CHRISTOPHER VILAKATI AND OTHERS
(Mr V. Kunene) (Mr M.P. Simelane)
COURT B
3. C OF A (CRI) 30/2012
BHEKI AMOS MKHALIPHI V
REX
(In Person) (The DPP’s Office)
4. C OF A (CRI) 10/2013
MANQOBA LEBOGANG MOKOENA V
REX
(In Person) (The DPP’s Office)
MONDAY 4 NOVEMBER 2013
COURT A
5. C OF A (CRI) 12/2013
MANDLA MLONDOLOZI MENDLULA
V
REX
(In Person) (The DPP’s Office)
6. C OF A (CRI ) 20/2011
MZILIKAZI MCINISELI MASEKO
V
REX
(In Person) (The DPP’s Office)
7. C OF A (CIV) 26/2013
MANDLENKOSI MASUKU
V
JABULANI SHABANGU
(Messrs S.S. Hlophe, CJ Littler) (Messrs M.Z. Mkhwanazi)
COURT B
8. C OF A (CRI) 2/2013
MANDLA BHEKITHEMBA MATSEBULA
V
REX
(In Person) (The DPP’s Chambers)
9. C OF A (CIV) 70/2012
SWAZILAND DEVELOPMENT SAVINGS BANK
V
KENNETH G. NGCAMPHALALA
(Mr S.C. Dlamini) (Mr M.M. Sibandze)
TUESDAY 5 NOVEMBER 2013
COURT A
10. C OF A (CIV) 17/2013
JABULANE PATRICK TIBANE
V
ALFRED SIPHO DLAMINI
(Messrs B. Mndzebele) (Messrs S.S. Hlophe)
COURT B
11. C OF A (CIV) 16/2013
THE CHAIRMAN OF THE ROAD TRANSPORT AND ANOTHER V
SIMON MNUMZANE VILANE
(Messrs V. Manana,) (A.G’S Office,) (Mr S.C. Dlamini)
WEDNESDAY 6 NOVEMBER 2013
COURT A
12. C OF A (CIV) 19/2013
ROBERT SAMKELO HADEBE
V NELISIWE NDLANGAMANDLA AND OTHERS
(Mr. S. Dlamini) (Mr Zonke Magagula)
COURT B
13. C OF A (CIV) 33/2013
MTN SWAZILAND LIMITED
V MAXI MUSIC (PTY) LTD
(Messrs S.V. Mdladla) (Nondumiso Mzileni - Mbelu Attorneys)
THURSDAY 7 NOVEMBER 2013
COURT A
14. C OF A (CIV) 8/2013
NEDBANK (SWAZILAND) LTD
V
KENNETH G. NGCAMPHALALA
(Mr. E.J. Henwood) (Mr S.C. Dlamini)
COURT B
15. C OF A (CIV) 38/2013
REUBEN BERNARD RAUTENBACH
V
ROSE RAUTENBACH
(Mr M.P. Simelane) (Messrs Rodrigues & Associates)
FRIDAY 8 NOVEMBER 2013
COURT A
16. C OF A (CIV) 44/2013
ISAAC SIGULUGWANE ZWANE
V
MAQALENI DLAMINI AND OTHERS
(Mr. S. Bhembe) (Attorney General’s Chambers)
COURT B
17. C OF A (CIV) 48/2013
AFRICAN ECHO (PTY) LTD AND OTHERS
V
INKHOSATANA GELANE SIMELANE AND OTHERS
(Mr M.M. Sibandze) (Messrs Robinson Bertram)
(Messrs M.S. Dlamini)
MONDAY 11 NOVEMBER 2013
COURT A
18. C OF A (CIV) 7/2013
RAYMOND NKOSINATHI DLAMINI AND ANOTHER
V
HELEN ZWANE AND OTHERS
(Mr S.C. Dlamini) (Mr L. Vilakati)
COURT B
19. C OF A (CIV) 24/2013
ELIAS K. DLAMINI AND OTHERS
V
THE MASTER OF THE HIGH COURT AND OTHERS
(Mr Ben Simelane ) (Mr M.M. Vilakati) (Mr Sonto Dlamini in person)
TUESDAY 12 NOVEMBER 2013
COURT A
20. C OF A (CIV) 45/2012
SANDLANE ZWANE t/a BULLNOSE BONANZA V
BUSISIWE KHANYILE (born Dlamini)
(Nkomondze Attorneys) (Bhembe Attorneys)
COURT B
21. C OF A (CIV) 52/2013
STEFANUTTI STOCKS (PTY) LTD
V
GOVERNMENT OF THE KINGDOM OF SWAZILAND AND OTHERS
(Mr E.J. Henwood) (Attorneys General’s Chambers)
(Mr L.R. Mamba)
WEDNESDAY 13 NOVEMBER 2013
COURT A
22. C OF A (CIV) 41/2013
NONTOBEKO MSIBI AND ANOTHER
V
PHUMUZA MSIBI N.O. AND OTHERS
(Mr N.S. Manzini)) (Mr S. Dlamini
THURSDAY 14 NOVEMBER 2013
COURT A
23. C OF A (CIV) 54/2013
JEKE (PTY) LTD
V
SAMUEL SOLOMON NKABINDE
(Mr L.R. Mamba) (Messrs Robinson Bertram)
COURT B
24. C OF A (CIV) 55/2013
MBABANE ESTATE AGENTS (PTY) LTD
V
KOWLOON FAST FOODS (PTY) LTD t/a KOWLOON GIFT SHOP
(Mr N.D. Jele) (Mr M.P. Simelane)
FRIDAY 15 NOVEMBER 2013
COURT A
25. C OF A (CIV) 5/2013
ANTOINETTE CHARMAINE HORTON
V
ROY DOUGLAS NICOLAS – FANOURAKIS AND OTHERS
(Malinga & Malinga) (Nkosi Attorneys)
COURT B
26. C OF A (CIV) 37/2013
AFRIKAN TYRES (PTY) LTD AND OTHERS
V
THE TAXING MASTER AND OTHERS
(Mr T.M. Ndlovu) (Messrs T. Simelane, S. Dlamini,
Magagula & Hlophe)
MONDAY 18 NOVEMBER 2013
COURT A
27. C OF A (CIV) 22/2013 REALHOLD (PTY) LTD
V
DAVID MASAKENI KUNENE
(Messrs M. Thwala) (Messrs S.C. Dlamini)
COURT B
28. C OF A (CIV) 32/2013 ZANDILE MARY NSIMBINI
V
NOMPHUMELELO PRISCA THIELE
(Messrs T.M. Ndlovu) (Messrs M. Mthethwa – CJ Littler)
WEDNESDAY 19 NOVEMBER 2013
COURT A
29. C OF A (CIV) 25/2013 THE SWAZILAND GOVERNMENT V
AARON NGOMANE
(Attorney General’s Chambers) (Messrs Ben J. Simelane)
COURT B
30. C OF A (CIV) 45/2013 CONICAL HILL (PTY) LTD V MOTSA INVESTMENT (PTY) LTD
(Mr E.J. HENWOOD) (Messrs Sibusiso Shongwe & Associates)
WEDNESDAY 20 NOVEMBER 2013
COURT A
31. C OF A (CIV) 58/2013 SWAZI MTN LIMITED AND OTHERS V
SWAZILAND POST AND TELECOMMUNICATION AND ANOTHER
(Magagula & Hlophe Attorneys) (Howe Masuku Nsibandze Attorneys)
THURSDAY 21 TO FRIDAY 28 NOVEMBER 2013
RESERVED FOR WRITING JUDGMENTS.
FRIDAY 29 NOVEMBER 2013 AT 0900 A.M.
DELIVERY OF JUDGEMENTS.
________________________
LORRAINE L. HLOPHE REGISTRAR OF THE SUPREME COURT
03 OCTOBER 2013